Blog
What Asterix And Google Have in Common
Sylvie Fodor, Executive Director
Byby Sylvie FodorOn 18 December 2009 a French court found Google guilty of "counterfeiting" and violating copyright of French publisher La Martinière by digitizing hundreds of books within their Google Book Search programme.
Google has to pay €300,000 ($430,000) in damages and interest to the plaintiff and stop digitizing and putting the books online. http://www.legipresse.com/newsletter/bandeaux/000001/000084.pdf
The importance of this ruling cannot be overestimated.
French law is very protective of copyright holders: there is therefore little surprise in the outcome of the case since the Judge used French law. The key point though is that the Judge used French law at all! Two months before, the exact same Court had ruled otherwise: in a very similar case opposing Google Images and French collecting society for visual artists, SAIF (http://www.legalis.net/jurisprudence-decision.php3?id_article=2776), the court ruled that "Fair Use" and not French Law was applicable - and deemed the showing of images as thumbnails in the search engine's browser as "fair use".
Between these two decisions lie Google Book Search and the Google Book Settlement. Digitization programmes of books, not thumbnail images, are a subject of public interest and of cultural identity.
In September 2009, the hearing organised by the European Commission was flocked by hundreds of delegates from all EU countries. In October 2009, German Chancellor Angela Merkel took position in a very clear statement : "We reject the scanning of books without any copyright protection - like Google is doing." In December 2009, French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, unveiled an ambitious spending plan pushing for a broader public digitisation programme with € 750million earmarked to ensure that French national treasures will be digitised.
For rightsholders in France - but not only in France - the decision of 18 December is a relief. First, it is of course easier (and cheaper) to sue at home if national law is applied rather than foreign law. In the case at hand, the judge rightly noted that "the majority" of "points of interests" is located in France, justifying the use of French Law. More importantly, the decision establishes a level playing field between parties in the big battle of mass digitization: the Web giant and the smaller providers of copyrighted content. Google has a yearly turnover of 21 billion dollars while the 12 largest French publishers together only 5 billion. "I was the only one who had the guts to sue Google" boasted Hervé de La Martinière in the French Media and some blogs depicted him as Asterix the indomitable Gaul crushing a Roman army of colourful Google soldiers.
Whether Google will finally win the day remains to be seen... The magic
potion has still not been brewed. However, thanks to this decision,
Google will be forced back to the table of negotiations and this is a
good thing.
Comments
More News
Archive
Latest Blog Entries
This is an Orphan Work too
The combination of groundbreaking technology and badly crafted legislation, could make any search of photographs, and by implication their authors, completely redundant. Read more
A Guinness in Dublin
Imagesource has found an original way to invite its partners to Dublin! Read more
Inside Brussels
New Digital Agenda Commissioner sets out her agenda. With the new Commission set to take office in early February, Neelie Kroes, who will take on the newly-created Digital Agenda portfolio, set out her ideas for the future. Read more
Online Antitrust Developments in Germany
There have been numerous developments in Germany recently that have brought focus to online competition issues in Europe and have seen Google come under heavy criticism. Read more
More Google USA
In the US, Various authors groups (The National Writers Union, the American Society of Journalists and Authors, and the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America) sent a letter on January 6, 2010, to members of Congress. Read more
HAPPY NEW DECADE!
The team here at CEPIC are feeling very excited and optimistic about what the future holds for our organisation and for all our members. Read more
Creating a CEPIC Community: Announcing the SOFT LAUNCH of CEPIC's new website
Dear Cepic Members and Friends of our Industry: As the Centre of the Picture Industry, we are happy to announce the soft launch of our new website on January 18th 2010. During the next few weeks there will be more input making the site more user friendly and informative for the membership. Read more
What Asterix And Google Have in Common
On 18 December 2009 a French court found Google guilty of "counterfeiting" and violating copyright of French publisher La Martinière by digitizing hundreds of books within their Google Book Search programme. Read more
Copyright Protection in the Age of Digital Piracy
There are various ways of affording some form of protection to your images. As a professional photographer, I depend significantly upon my website to sell my images. Read more
Intellectual Property is a Human Right in Europe
On December 1st, 2009 the Treaty of Lisbon became valid as the basic EU set of rules. Remarkably, the Treaty of Lisbon contains a Charter of Human Rights compulsory for all Member States of the European Union and all national or European Courts. Read more
Up-date : second round
This is an up-date on this article.
Google has gone into appeal. The decision is expected for March 23rd.
Google has refused to publish the condemnation of the court on their website, saying that this decision throws a negative light on Google Book !